Grok says:
Key Points
- Research suggests yoga can cause injuries, but the risk is relatively low with proper practice.
- The 2012 New York Times article highlighted real risks, but its claim that most should give up yoga seems exaggerated.
- Studies since 2012 show increased injuries, especially among older adults, but safety measures can help.
- There’s ongoing debate about yoga’s safety, with some seeing it as gentle and others noting potential harm.
Article Accuracy
The 2012 New York Times article "How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body" was partially accurate in noting that yoga can lead to injuries like musculoskeletal issues and strains. However, its suggestion that most people should abandon yoga due to high injury risk seems overstated. Recent research indicates that while injuries have increased, especially among older adults, the overall risk is low compared to other physical activities, and many injuries are mild and recoverable with proper precautions.
Updates on Related Matters
Since 2012, studies have shown a rise in yoga-related injuries, particularly for those over 65, with emergency department visits nearly doubling from 2001 to 2014 (Yoga-Related Injuries in the United States From 2001 to 2014). However, a systematic review found most injuries are transient, with risks similar to non-yoga exercises (Adverse events associated with yoga: a systematic review). Recent discussions emphasize safer practices, like working with certified instructors and being mindful of limits, to reduce risks (Study Finds Yoga Injuries Are on the Rise).
Comprehensive Analysis of the 2012 New York Times Article and Updates on Yoga Injuries
This analysis delves into the accuracy of the 2012 New York Times article "How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body" and provides a detailed overview of updates on related matters, focusing on yoga-related injuries and safety. The discussion is informed by a review of subsequent research and media coverage, aiming to offer a balanced perspective for practitioners and interested readers.
Background and Context
The article, published on January 5, 2012, by William J. Broad, sparked significant controversy by highlighting potential injuries from yoga, such as popped ribs, brain injuries, and lower back issues (How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body). It featured insights from yoga teacher Glenn Black, suggesting that yoga could be harmful for the majority and should be limited to those in good physical condition or for therapeutic use. This claim was met with backlash from the yoga community, with responses arguing that the article was sensationalist and missed the broader benefits of yoga (Response to NYT Article - How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body).
Assessing the Article's Accuracy
To evaluate the article's accuracy, we examined its main claims against subsequent research. The article posited five key points, as detailed in the following table:
Main Claims | Evidence Presented in Article |
|---|---|
Yoga can cause physical harm, not just healing. | Author's personal experience: ruptured disk in 2007 during extended-side-angle pose. |
Most people should give up yoga due to injury risk. | Glenn Black's belief: "the vast majority of people" should stop, as it's too likely to cause harm. |
Celebrated teachers also injure themselves. | Black's observation: many teachers have underlying weaknesses, making serious injury inevitable. |
Yoga is only for those in good physical condition or therapeutically, not for general classes. | Black's statement: "Yoga is for people in good physical condition. Or it can be used therapeutically. It’s controversial to say, but it really shouldn’t be used for a general class." |
Specific poses can be dangerous. | Example: Black witnessed a yogi’s three ribs break during a spinal twist in India; avoids teaching inversions like headstands and shoulder stands. |
- Support for Claims: Recent studies confirm that yoga can indeed cause injuries, particularly musculoskeletal issues, with a 2016 study noting nearly 29,590 yoga-related emergency department visits from 2001 to 2014, with injuries doubling by 2014 (Yoga-Related Injuries in the United States From 2001 to 2014). Another review found that nearly two-thirds of musculoskeletal injuries affect the lower extremity, supporting the article's focus on specific pose risks (Although the injury rate of yoga is low, nearly two-thirds of musculoskeletal injuries in yoga affect the lower extremity).
- Exaggeration of Risk: However, the claim that most people should give up yoga is not supported by evidence. A 2017 systematic review found that while 22.7% of yoga practitioners experience adverse events during a class, most are mild and transient, with risks comparable to non-yoga exercises (Adverse events associated with yoga: a systematic review). This suggests the article may have overstated the danger, contributing to the controversy noted in responses like those from The Guardian (Yoga can damage your body' article throws exponents off-balance).
Updates on Yoga Injuries Since 2012
Since the article's publication, several studies and articles have provided updates on yoga injuries, revealing trends and safety considerations:
- Increased Injury Rates: Research indicates a rise in yoga-related injuries, particularly among older adults. A 2016 study found that injuries among those 65 and older increased more than eightfold from 2001 to 2014, attributed to factors like decreased bone density and pre-existing conditions (Study Finds Yoga Injuries Are on the Rise). This aligns with media reports from 2018 suggesting social media and the push for advanced poses contribute to this trend (Yoga injuries land more people in hospital than ever before, study finds).
- Types and Prevalence: Most injuries are musculoskeletal, with a 2019 survey reporting 0.60 injuries per 1000 hours of practice, highest in Power Yoga at 1.50 injuries per 1000 hours (Adverse effects of yoga: a national cross-sectional survey). Another study noted that 76.9% of acute cases and 51.6% of chronic cases reach full recovery, indicating many injuries are not permanent (Adverse effects of yoga: a national cross-sectional survey).
- Risk Factors and Prevention: Older practitioners, beginners, and those practicing without supervision are at higher risk. A 2017 article highlighted the lack of national certification for yoga instructors in the U.S., potentially leading to unsafe teaching practices (Insight From Injury). Safety measures include practicing with certified instructors, using adaptive yoga for those with conditions, and avoiding forcing into poses, as noted in a 2019 blog post (7 Prominent Yogis Weigh in on Yoga Injuries and What to Do About Them).
Discussion and Implications
The article's focus on injury risks was valid but contributed to a polarized debate, with some viewing yoga as inherently dangerous and others defending its benefits. Recent research leans toward a balanced view, acknowledging risks but emphasizing that yoga can be safe with proper precautions. The increase in injuries since 2012 underscores the need for better education and regulation, particularly for teaching older or less experienced practitioners. This aligns with ongoing discussions in yoga communities about responsible practice and teacher training, as seen in a 2025 Yoga Journal article (Why Are So Many People Getting Yoga Injuries?).
In conclusion, while the 2012 article was accurate in highlighting yoga's potential for injury, it seems likely that its alarmist tone overstated the risk for the general population. Updates since then show a nuanced picture, with increased injuries but also clear pathways to safer practice, ensuring yoga remains accessible and beneficial for many.
Key Citations
